Artisanal Icons at Bake Shoppe in Toronto

Pop Tart lovers, rejoice. Now you can have a handcrafted artisanal version of your favourite childhood treat, thanks to of-the-moment Bake Shoppe at College and Ossington.

In a variety of flavours—including double chocolate, gourmet jam and nutella—these morsels have redefined the toaster pastry category. And given that you can get a message handwritten in icing on the tart, birthday cupcakes are quaking in their wrappers.

This café oozes appeal with its other tasty treats as well, including homemade flakies and s’mores bars. And these folks can really bring it on the custom orders—we spied a 3D can of Campbell’s soup and a bust of Snoop Dog, all in cake form.

From pop culture to pop tarts, Bake Shoppe, we love you.

If your sweet tooth is beckoning, we’ve got 19 more of the Best Spots for Birthday Party Treats in Toronto to sastify your craving.